Airlines’ Challenge of Ad Rule Hits End of Runway at US Supreme Court

On April 1, 2013, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear a challenge by three U.S. airlines to DOT’s rule requiring that all fees and taxes be included in advertised airfares.  The “rule” is actually DOT’s most recent interpretation of 14 CFR Section 399.84, the “full fare advertising rule,” which governs the advertising of fares by both carriers and ticket agents.

Prior to January 26, 2012, for enforcement purposes, DOT interpreted Section 399.84 as allowing for taxes and government-imposed fees collected by carriers and ticket agents (such as passenger facility charges and departure taxes) to be stated separately from base fares in advertisements.   Ticket agent and carrier-imposed fees, however, (i.e. surcharges for fuel or insurance) were required to be included in the advertised fare.   (See a DOT Order dated December 28, 2012, discussing the restrictions under DOT’s prior interpretation of the rule).

Read more ›

Posted in Recent Developments In Aviation Law

DOT May Prohibit Some Alitalia Flights due to Italy’s Airport User Fees

For many years U.S. air carriers have argued that Italy’s two-tiered airport user fees are discriminatory.  Italy’s airports charge lower landing and take-off fees for intra-EU flights, while fees for extra-EU flights (those going to or from Italy via a foreign location) are much higher.  Both DOT and the U.S. State Department have argued to the European Union (and directly to Italian authorities) that these different fees discriminate against U.S. carriers and violate the user charges provision (Article 12) of the U.S.-EU Air Transport Agreement (“the Agreement”).   Italy, however, has steadfastly refused to lower the fees.  The EU recently required the Italian government to justify the higher fees or eliminate them, but resolution of the issue from the EU side could take many months.

Read more ›

Posted in Recent Developments In Aviation Law

Cozen Aviation Lawyers Author Summary of U.S. Aviation Law

Cozen O’Connor aviation attorneys Mark Atwood and Allan Mendelsohn were selected by the Global Legal Group to provide an overview of U.S. aviation law in the International Comparative Legal Guide to Aviation Law 2013. The Global Legal Group (GLG) publishes cross-border summaries of law in several different practice areas. The publication is the first aviation law summary offered by the GLG, and provides an overview of the aviation laws in 27 countries, including the U.S., Canada, Germany, Mexico, and the United Kingdom, among others. We believe that this guide will prove an invaluable reference for both aviation attorneys and the airline industry, and we look forward to watching the growth of this publication in the years to come.

Posted in Recent Developments In Aviation Law

Major Air Carrier Nations Oppose EU Emissions Trading Scheme

With less than two months to go before the European Union’s controversial Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) takes effect for air transport, non-European nations are starting to take action to prevent application of this scheme to non-EU carriers. Beginning January 1, 2012, the ETS would require airlines – whether they are European or not – to have emissions “credits” in order to operate into the EU. These credits must cover the entire estimated amount of CO2 that the operation is expected to emit. The ETS has been in force since 2005 for other industries, including ground transport, but until now it has not been applied to air services.

Read more ›

Posted in EU Emissions Trading Scheme

President Signs 2012 FAA Reauthorization Act

On February 15, 2012, President Obama signed into law the reauthorization act for the FAA (titled the “FAA Modernization and Reform Act of 2012” (H.R. 658)). The Act is the first longterm funding for the FAA in 5 years.  Because of ongoing Congressional partisan bickering over the Act, the FAA has instead been funded since 2007 by 23 short-term extensions. While most of the discussion about the Act has been its $63 billion in funding for the FAA through 2015 and its ratcheting up of pressure on the FAA to complete the NextGen air traffic control system, the Act also contains some notable provisions for the air carrier industry.

Read more ›

Tagged with: , , ,
Posted in Essential Air Service, EU Emissions Trading Scheme, FAA Legislation, Reauthorization Act 2012, Tarmac Delays

French High Court Rules That Forum Non Conveniens Doesn’t Apply in U.S. Air Crash Suit

On December 7, 2011, the French high court, the Cour de Cassation, ruled that a United States District Court could not use the doctrine of forum non conveniens under Article 33 of the 1999 Montreal Convention to transfer to Martinique suits brought because of the crash of a Colombian air carrier. The case had been dismissed by the U.S. District Court on the grounds that forum non conveniens is an available procedural tool under Article 33, and that the doctrine favored litigation in Martinique where all of the crash victims resided or were citizens. That decision was affirmed by the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals. It is expected that the plaintiffs will soon refile their suit in the United States.

Read more ›

Tagged with: ,
Posted in Forum Non Conveniens, Montreal Convention, Recent Developments In Aviation Law

Major Air Carrier Nations Oppose EU Emissions Trading Schemes

With less than two months to go before the European Union’s controversial Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) takes effect for air transport, non-European nations are starting to take action to prevent application of this scheme to non-EU carriers. Beginning January 1, 2012, the ETS would require airlines – whether they are European or not – to have emissions “credits” in order to operate into the EU. These credits must cover the entire estimated amount of CO2 that the operation is expected to emit. The ETS has been in force since 2005 for other industries, including ground transport, but until now it has not been applied to air services.

Read more ›

Tagged with: , , , ,
Posted in EU Emissions Trading Scheme

Legal Aspects of Aircraft Lease Agreements

Mark Atwood, of Cozen O’Connor’s Washington D.C. Office, spoke last month at a legal seminar in Dubai, UAE, on “Legal Aspects of Aircraft Lease Agreements,” co-sponsored by Cozen O’Connor and United Insurance Brokers. Participants included representatives of carriers and leasing companies in the UAE, Qatar, Bangladesh and Kenya. The seminar, which covered operating leases, wet leases and the insurance aspects of aircraft leases, was the latest of several such seminars held earlier this year in Washington and London under the auspices of AeroPodium. The next leasing seminar is scheduled for December 9 in the firm’s Washington D.C. office.  Details can be found at AeroPodium.

The level of participation at the seminar pointed up the extent to which the UAE and Qatar are becoming major hubs not only of international air service, but of all manner of aviation and aerospace activity.

Tagged with: ,
Posted in Aircraft Leasing, Insurance

Germany Reduces Airline Passenger Ticket Tax due to EU Emissions Trading Scheme

Germany is already working to reduce the financial impact of the European Union’s emissions trading scheme on air travelers. The German government announced this week that it will cut its controversial plane ticket tax next year to compensate for additional costs arising from the scheme. The ticket tax is currently imposed at rates of EUR8, 25, 45 (USD10.98, 34.32, 61.78), per passenger depending on the destination.  In order to entice consumers to fly even in the face of additional charges stemming from the emissions trading scheme, the German finance ministry is reducing the tax across the board by 5.52%. It is hoped that this will ease the burden for travelers who it is estimated will be faced with costs of between EUR2 to EUR12 (USD2.75 to 16.47) per ticket to cover airline charges for the scheme.

Read more ›

Tagged with: ,
Posted in EU Emissions Trading Scheme

FAA Inspector “Cooling Off” Rule Takes Effect October 21

On October 21, 2011, the FAA’s new “cooling off” rule will take effect. The rule requires a two-year “cooling off” period before former FAA safety inspectors can represent certificate holders on certain matters before the FAA.  It applies to all entities holding certificates under the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR).  This includes FAR Part 121, 125 and 135 operators and Part 91K fractional program managers, as well as Part 145 repair stations, specialized rotorcraft and agricultural operations, and instructional schools.

Read more ›

Tagged with: ,
Posted in Inspector "Cooling Off" Rule
Aviation Law Advisor
Cozen O’Connor’s aviation attorneys are committed to keeping their clients apprised of recent developments in the aviation industry. The world of aviation is complex and fast-moving with many participants, including aircraft manufacturers, air carriers, airports, airport operators, FBOs, repair stations and maintenance providers, insurers, airline investors, corporate and private aircraft owners and operators, and aircraft leasing and management companies. Our clients are in every sector of the industry. This blog is just one tool that we use to keep them updated on the litigation, regulatory, legislative and international developments that affect their operations every day.
Subscribe to our Posts

Email: